Update: Glenn Reynolds,
of Instapundit fame, writes
in Popular Mechanics about why this recommendation is wrong. He also notes importantly that this is just a recommendation—they are not going
to coerce states into this as I wonder below. You would
tend to think that if they were just making recommendations, they would make sure
that the recommendations were not so completely idiotic that they would be
rejected out of hand. And at Instapundit, he has more.
So the news comes
out today that the NTSB wants the states to ban all of the use of cell phones,
except in emergencies. From Cnn’s
article:
A
federal safety board called Tuesday for a nationwide ban on the use of cell
phones and text messaging devices while driving.
The
recommendation is the most far-reaching yet by the National Transportation
Safety Board, which in the past 10 years has increasingly sought to limit the
use of portable electronic devices -- recommending bans for novice drivers,
school bus drivers and commercial truckers. Tuesday's recommendation, if
adopted by states, would outlaw non-emergency phone calls and texting by
operators of every vehicle on the road.
But there was one
line in that Cnn report that puzzled me:
It
would apply to hands-free as well as hand-held devices, but devices installed
in the vehicle by the manufacturer would be allowed, the NTSB said.
When I read that, I wondered
what the hell they were talking about. I
mean I hadn’t seen a cell phone that was permanently installed in a car since Bill
Clinton was President. I considered
several interpretations, but rather than speculate, I went and found the
NTSU’s official
releases, to see if it might shed some light on the matter.
The truth of the
matter is that they are talking about something much more radical. Take this language from the main index page
for this “Gray Summit” providing recommendations:
To the 50 states and the District of
Columbia:
1. (1) Ban the nonemergency use of portable
electronic devices (other than those designed to support the driving task) for
all drivers; (2) use the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration model
of high visibility enforcement to support these bans; and (3) implement
targeted communication campaigns to inform motorists of the new law and enforcement,
and to warn them of the dangers associated with the nonemergency use of
portable electronic devices while driving. (H-11-XX)
Folks, they are not
talking about cell phones only. They are
talking all electronic devices. And if
you were uncertain just how radical their intentions are in this, take this screencap
of a slide from the Power Point style
presentation
they gave: